Musgraves Mixes Melancholy And Melodies On 'A Very Kacey Christmas'

DAVE DAVIES, HOST:

This is FRESH AIR. I'm Dave Davies in for Terry Gross, who's out sick today. Last week, our guest Tony and Oscar-winner Joel Grey received the 25th Oscar Hammerstein Award for lifetime achievement in musical theater. Grey originated the role of the master of ceremonies in the Broadway show "Cabaret." He explains how he brought this decadent character to life in the memoir "Master Of Ceremonies." The memoir's about his work on stage and screen. He was in the original Broadway productions of "Cabaret," "Chicago" and "Wicked."

As a boy, he performed with his father, Mickey Katz, a clarinetist who performed Yiddish novelty versions of pop songs. The memoir's also about Joel Grey's private life. When he was young, he was attracted to boys. But while he did have some relationships, he thought it was too risky to be gay. He fell in love with an actress. They married and raised two children, including Jennifer Grey. Then they divorced. Grey publicly came out last year at the age of 82.

Before we hear Terry's interview with Joel Grey, let's start with a song he'll always be associated with - "Willkommen" from "Cabaret," which is set in Germany in the 1930s. As the sleazy, sinister, lascivious master of ceremonies, Grey welcomes the audience into the cabaret while outside the Nazi's power is growing in politics and on the streets.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSICAL, "CABARET")

JOEL GREY: (Singing) Willkommen, bienvenue, welcome, fremder, etranger, stranger, glucklich zu sehen, je suis enchante, happy to see you, bleibe, reste, stay. Willkommen and bienvenue, welcome im cabaret, au cabaret, to cabaret. Meine damen und herren, mes dames et messieurs, ladies and gentlemen, guten abend, bon soir, good evening. Wie geht's? Comment ca va? Do you feel good? Ich bin eur confrencier. Je suis votre compere. I am your host. Und sage willkommen, bienvenue, welcome im cabaret, au cabaret, to cabaret. Leave your troubles outside. So life is disappointing. Forget it. In here, life is beautiful. The girls beautiful. Even the orchestra is beautiful.

TERRY GROSS, HOST:

Joel Grey, welcome to FRESH AIR. So let's start with "Cabaret." You write that you discovered the character of the emcee, the way you wanted to play him, in a dream that you had about a comic that you found really offensive. Would you - would you describe that comic who is inspired by a real offensive comic (laughter) that you saw in real life?

GREY: When I was working in nightclubs, I went to a nightclub in St. Louis, Mo., and there was supposedly the hot guy in town. And he was disgusting, and he sweated and cajoled and begged the audience for applause. And I thought to myself, this is the worst thing I've ever seen, and the worst thing about that was that the audience loved him. And I thought, how can this be?

GROSS: Oh, and you write that he was telling every kind of stereotypical joke - take-my-wife jokes, fat jokes, crude sex jokes, fag impressions with lisping and mincing - I'm quoting you here (laughter). And, you know, you hated him and the audience loved him.

GREY: I was confused, but somewhere, that always stuck in my mind. And I thought to myself - when I was rehearsing and not quite getting it, I thought to myself, what if I pretended - which is what actors do - what if I pretended I was this dreadful, overdone, extraordinarily horrible emcee and if I tried it on top of the "Cabaret" emcee? And we had a rehearsal and one day I did it, and I felt so horrible showing that sort of part of myself that I even understood when I watched it. And when I was finished, I ran to the back of the stage and hid. I was so mortified thinking everyone would think that was me. A few minutes later, I felt an arm around my shoulder and it was Hal Prince, and he looked at me and he said, Joelie (ph), that's it.

GROSS: And this is when you got the idea of being, like, leering and doing things like picking up the skirt of one of the Kit Kat girls in the club with your cane, you know, and being...

GREY: Yeah, practically touching their breasts and just totally defiling and disgusting behavior.

GROSS: And that was great. That was (laughter) and that's how the character should have been.

GREY: I guess so. And then we started to think about how he looked. And I found a makeup that was sort of like a marionette, sort of feminine and sort of masculine. He had this lipstick and this little beard right under the lip that was so manly. So he was clearly a complicated-looking guy, but the audience thought he was swell.

GROSS: So you grew up basically in show business. You know, you started your career when you were young. But when you were a child, you'd be in the orchestra pit of vaudeville theatres because your father was performing. Your father Mickey Katz was a clarinetist. Your father performed in pit bands. Your father performed with Spike Jones. Spike Jones was famous for his parodies of pop songs. Then your father...

GREY: And he was also famous for glugs. Do you know what glugs are?

GROSS: Yeah, do one.

GREY: (Glugging sound). Well, you know...

GROSS: That's great. So that's...

GREY: He was very good at it.

GROSS: Your father did that on Spike Jones records.

GREY: Right.

GROSS: Did he teach you, or did you just pick it up?

GREY: I think it was just there.

GROSS: It was just there, OK.

GREY: Yep.

GROSS: So then your father went on his own and led his own band. And instead of doing English parodies of pop songs, your father was doing, like, Yiddish parodies of pop songs that were part English, part Yiddish and had a lot of Jewish culture jokes in them. I want to play an example...

GREY: And they were...

GROSS: ...Of that - yeah.

GREY: They were brilliant. They really had a kind of political aspect to them that I think people never gave him credit for. And there were those people who didn't want to have Yiddish spoken on the radio or even in the theater because they were trying to assimilate. And that never stopped him because he was trying to create something like taking a pop song or an American song like "Home On The Range" and Yiddishizing (ph) it to make a sense of inclusion for the Jewish people, that they could be part of a truly American song. (Singing in Yiddish).

GROSS: (Laughter).

GREY: And people listened, even people who did not know any Yiddish thought this is funny.

GROSS: So let's play a song that's not going to be exactly a direct copy of the American lyrics (laughter). This is "St. Louis Blues." And I'm choosing this for two reasons. One, it's a great Mickey Katz recording, and two, he actually played "St. Louis Blues" at a talent show in high school, played it straight. So here's Joel Grey's father Mickey Katz with his band doing "St. Louis Blues" in Yiddish.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "ST. LOUIS BLUES")

MICKEY KATZ: (Singing) Oh, I hate to see that evening sun go down. (Singing in Yiddish) that evening sun go down. (Singing in Yiddish). Now, listen up now. She's (singing in Yiddish). St. Louis misery. (Singing in Yiddish). Yeah, yeah. (Singing in Yiddish) diamond brooch. Yeah, diamond brooch.

(LAUGHTER)

GREY: St. Louis maidel.

GROSS: Yeah, and maidel is a girl, right?

GREY: Right.

GROSS: Yeah, so what else is he saying there? Like when he says she's kaftig (ph) and zaftig. Zaftig means kind of big, right?

GREY: Yes.

GROSS: And what does kaftig mean?

GREY: I don't know.

GROSS: You don't know, OK.

GREY: I never learned to speak Yiddish ever. It was just something that was learned by rote and I guess my deep background.

GROSS: Because you performed with your father in his show "Borscht Capades..."

GREY: (Laughter).

GROSS: ...As in "Ice Capades" but Borscht Belt. And you had to sing to...

GREY: It was not...

GROSS: Yeah.

GREY: It was not skating on borscht.

GROSS: (Laughter) Frozen borscht. So you had to sing Yiddish songs in this - or sing songs that had Yiddish in it, but I guess you just learned that - learned the pronunciations and learned what each word meant in context. You did at least that, right? Yeah.

GREY: Yes, I learned by rote.

GROSS: So why don't we hear you singing one of the songs that you sang with your father. In fact, this is the first song I think that you sang with him. And early in your career, before you were in "Cabaret," you recorded an album called "Songs My father Taught Me." So this is from side one, track one of a vinyl recording (laughter), the original pressing I think of "Songs My Father Taught Me." This is "Rumania, Rumania." How do you even know this song?

GREY: Because it was a hit song on Second Avenue. It was made famous by a great performer called Aaron Lebedeff. And Danny Kaye imitated him, and I got to, too.

GROSS: OK, so this is Joel Grey circa...

GREY: Circa 1950s.

GROSS: OK, very good. So here's "Rumania, Rumania."

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "RUMANIA, RUMANIA")

GREY: (Singing in Yiddish).

(Singing in Yiddish).

GROSS: So do you have any idea what you're singing in that song?

GREY: A little bit, not a lot.

GROSS: Just - so it's about getting nostalgic for Rumania, the old country?

GREY: Yes, yes, and all the foods that they had there that they don't have here. You know, to live there is such pleasure, but that was the sad part is that it was no longer possible to live there.

GROSS: So when you were young and you were singing with your father and doing Yiddish songs like "Rumania," what did you think your future was going to be? You couldn't be your father's son in your father's show forever, nor did you want to be.

GREY: That's true. I had begun my professional career when I was 9 years old at the Cleveland Play House. And it was a very specific real theater, and I thought the theater was the greatest place I had ever been. And that's what I wanted to do. And I thought I was going to be an actor in stock, you know, in doing small parts one month and leads the next.

But since there was no place to act, there was no play house in Los Angeles, I wanted to get onstage. And "Rumania" was the road. And my dad wrote an opening song for me that I would like - if it's OK with you - to sing for you.

GROSS: Oh, please.

GREY: (Singing) When I was eight days old, they named me Yossel (ph). Oh, what a (singing in Yiddish), such a celebration. All my (singing in Yiddish) drank a toast (singing in Yiddish) while I was suffering a minor operation.

GROSS: (Laughter).

GREY: (Singing) Later on, I went to kindergarten. I said, teacher, Yossel is my name. She said the name of Yossel. It sounds like a schlimazel. From Yossel, my name became Joel Grey.

GROSS: (Laughter).

DAVIES: Terry Gross and Joel Grey. We'll hear more after a break. This is FRESH AIR.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

DAVIES: Let's get back to Terry's interview with Joel Grey. His memoir is called "Master Of Ceremonies."

GROSS: So you had an affair when you were a teenager. You had a couple, actually. And one of them was with a cantor who was 25 years old - about six years older than you. He also was closeted, but then he decided he needed to get married. So he marries a girl, then you have a threesome (laughter) you describe in the book.

And then the girl tells her - the woman tells her mother. The mother says that she needs to get an annulment now. And that you would be named in the annulment as an example - you know, you'd be named in the - whatever the document is calling for the annulment as an example of why this marriage needed to be annulled. And that terrified you because you would be outed through this.

GREY: And my father would be finished. He had just started to really gain some strength in his career in Los Angeles. And if that ended up happening, it could have really hurt him.

GROSS: Right because he was - he's a performer, you know, so the public has to like him. And if the public isn't going to like him if he has a gay son, you'd be ruining his career.

GREY: Yes. So I went home and said to my folks what had happened. And there was quiet. Then I went to my mother and she said, don't touch me. Don't touch me. You disgust me. And then my father - she left, left the room.

I was devastated. My father said, let's go for a ride. And he was sweet and generous and loving, but my mother was sort of my world. And in that moment, my world was crumbling.

And that was at the time when they were taking men from gay bars to jail and entrapment. And I overheard all that stuff and I thought, this is so dangerous and so shameful. And, you know, when I think back now, he - it was some kind of abuse because I was 15. And I didn't know better.

GROSS: I didn't realize you were that young.

GREY: Yeah.

GROSS: So he was, like, 10 years older than you?

GREY: (Laughter) Anyway it was a nightmare that took me a lot of hours of therapy to get over.

GROSS: Did your therapist try to convince you to go straight?

GREY: The ideas then were that you could be - you know, play around when you're a teenager. That was kind of all right. Not really, but it wasn't serious because it was considered developmental (laughter) then.

GROSS: You mean like you'd grow out of it?

GREY: Yes. Yes. And so I didn't know quite what I was because I was very busy in high school sleeping with girls and having kind of torrid affairs with women. So I didn't know what I was. But I did get the idea that if I was queer, forget about a career. Forget about mother, first. And then forget about a career.

DAVIES: Terry Gross speaking with Joel Grey in February. His memoir is called "Master Of Ceremonies." After a break, we'll hear about his decision as a young man to get married in spite of his feelings for men, and his decision when he was 82 to come out publicly. I'm Dave Davies, and this is FRESH AIR.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

DAVIES: This is FRESH AIR. I'm Dave Davies in for Terry Gross, who's out sick today. Let's get back to Terry's interview with Joel Grey, who became famous for his role in "Cabaret" as the decadent master of ceremonies. He originated the role on Broadway and played it in the film adaptation, winning both a Tony and an Oscar. He's written a memoir called "Master Of Ceremonies." Grey came out publicly last year. In his memoir, he writes about his early attraction to boys, and his fear of the consequences he and his family would face if he was gay.

GROSS: You write that when you were growing up, it felt as if danger lurked around every corner of your childhood. Your mother was prone to erratic angry moods. When she got really angry, she'd beat you with a brush, push you out of the room with a broom. And in terms of danger lurking around every corner of your childhood, there was the shadow of the Holocaust. Your feelings for boys, you thought that that would make everybody hate you. And then you were very short and you felt kind of freakish because of that. So how do you think feeling that there was danger lurking around every corner affected you psychologically when you were growing up?

GREY: I'm certain it had a very dark effect on my soul and on my whole being because I didn't understand it. I didn't understand why that word fagelah, which was a derision, a word that was used by people to call them faggots.

GROSS: It's a Yiddish word. It means bird, right? So...

GREY: Little bird fluttering...

GROSS: Right.

GREY: ...You know...

GROSS: So...

GREY: ...Feminine.

GROSS: Yeah, so it was a derogative word, dismissive word to - that Jewish people would use, a Yiddish word to put down people who were gay. Oh, he's just a fagelah. So you were afraid you'd be called that.

GREY: Yes, and I heard the darkness when that word was used.

GROSS: So you eventually got married. How old were you when you got married?

GREY: Twenty-nine.

GROSS: So you married an actress, Jo Wilder. And did you convince yourself that you were straight? Did you believe you were straight at that point? Like, what was going on in terms of genuine feeling and denial in wanting to get married to a woman?

GREY: Well, I had always thought that I would get married and have children. And, you know, since women were a big part of my life and men were a small part of my life, I thought as the therapists would say I'd grow out of it. And I didn't. However, when I met Jo Wilder, I fell crazy in love and never thought about homosexuality. And I thought, well, this is what I'm supposed to be doing. This is life. Plus, all those years I was performing from the time I was 16. I was on The Eddie Cantor show. I went to London Palladium. I was really having a great success.

GROSS: So you convinced your wife to get married to you before it seems - the way you put it in the book, she wasn't ready yet but you wanted it so badly you got her to commit. You wanted to have a child so badly, you convinced her to have a child before she might have felt ready because she was pursuing her own career. And...

GREY: Right.

GROSS: ...It's very sad, your first child was born prematurely and died soon after. You and your wife were heartbroken. And then she gave birth a little over a year later. And, you know, you were on your way to having the family that you really wanted.

At the same time, it really was hard for your wife because you were on the road and you wanted her with you. You really wanted her to not work. And there was one time you were having a bit of an emotional meltdown and you begged her to come and be with you because you were performing away from home in "The Roar Of The Greasepaint."

But in the meantime, she was the understudy for Barbara Cook, the great Barbara Cook, in the Sheldon Harnick, Jerry Bock musical "She Loves Me" on Broadway. She gave that up to be with you and kind of gave up her career for you and the children. Did you understand why she didn't want to give up her career?

GREY: Of course. Of course. That was certainly a valid wish on her part. But I also knew that she was very mixed about becoming an actress and auditioning. She was very insecure and was halfway on the stage and halfway in the house. And I really thought that her depressions from going to an audition and not getting it would hurt our family. But I did say if you need to do it, do it. But she did not seem to get much pleasure from it.

GROSS: So you thought because of that that it was OK, that maybe she'd even be happier if she gave up her career.

GREY: That's what I thought.

GROSS: And do you think you were right?

GREY: I - I don't know. You never know about whether you were right in a choice. But I think - I think she was of many minds about working and being a mom and a wife. And I thought that since there were many minds that since we had these children and I have this career and we were busy and it was all very exciting and she seemed to like to share the limelight with me and be my beautiful wife, my beautiful, smart, talented wife. And she certainly could have said at the beginning I must have a career. I need to do that. And that was a possibility, but it didn't happen.

GROSS: So after 24 years of marriage, you decided to tell your wife about your past, about how you had had relationships with men when you were young. And I think you told her that that was in the past and things changed...

GREY: No, I...

GROSS: ...When you got married, yeah.

GREY: Not in the past, just - not even - I didn't consider it any longer. And I thought there was something inauthentic about how I was loving her in terms of her knowing me. And that's why I decided to tell her I had no interest in men and I was not acting out. I was totally in love with her. And, you know, nothing happens that's not supposed to happen. It just moved us along in terms of separating and, you know, finding another life, which she did and which I began.

GROSS: So the marriage ended. You didn't want it to end. Did you know who you were after that or what you wanted?

GREY: Not really. Not really. It took another couple of years of therapy, I would say. And...

GROSS: So this was, like, 1981 when the marriage ended, right?

GREY: '84, '83. And then what comes my way but "The Normal Heart."

GROSS: The Larry Kramer - this is that Larry Kramer play about men during the AIDS epidemic - gay men...

GREY: Right.

GROSS: ...During the AIDS epidemic.

GREY: And I went to a preview, and it was so amazing. People were crying out in the audience, sobbing, and all these names were on the walls. And everybody knew someone on that wall, so it was a terrifying time. And I decided that if there was ever a possibility of my doing it, I thought as an actor, I really need to do that.

And as life would have it, a few weeks later, Joe Papp called me and said Brad Davis, who was playing the role of Ned, has AIDS, and he's leaving the show and can you rehearse for 10 days and go in playing Ned Weeks? And it was a powerful experience. I got to be a gay man onstage.

GROSS: Were you a gay man offstage at that time?

GREY: No.

GROSS: And why not?

GREY: I was - a lot of damage had been done. The whole gay movement had - in a way, I ostracized myself to stay clear and loving in my marriage with my children that I sort of erased that from my life. And that was deep.

GROSS: So once you'd come out onstage - in other words, once you were playing a gay man onstage, did it make it any easier to come out after that?

GREY: Not really because I had so many years of hiding. That part of me was damaged and hiding.

DAVIES: We're listening to Terry's interview with Joel Grey. His memoir about his life and career is "Master Of Ceremonies." We'll hear more after a break. This is FRESH AIR.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

DAVIES: Let's get back to Terry's interview with Joel Grey. He's written a memoir called "Master Of Ceremonies." It's about his life in theater in roles such as the emcee in "Cabaret," George M. Cohan in "George M!" and the wizard in "Wicked." He was in a recent revival of "Anything Goes." The book is also about coming to terms with being gay.

GROSS: I think you only publicly came out last year. Do I have that right?

GREY: Yes.

GROSS: So what was the turning point for you and had you already been out to friends by then?

GREY: I had already been out for about 10, 15 years to my close friends and my co-workers, and I was fine in that respect. And I still thought then that it was a career-breaker. And only in the past couple of years has that changed.

GROSS: What changed for you that enabled you to come out publicly?

GREY: The law, that amazing beautiful law that happened and...

GROSS: You're talking about marriage equality?

GREY: Yes. And the fact that people were marrying who they wanted to marry, and they were having children. I was grateful for all that happening, and it was just one day that I was walking around thinking life is not what it was. It's changed, and you've changed. You better say it out loud, and I stood there in the sunshine and said I'm a gay man.

GROSS: How old were you then about 80?

GREY: Seventy-nine - what, you know...

GROSS: Does it...

GREY: Once a year or two at that point.

GROSS: Yeah. I don't know how - this may be too personal and I'm not quite sure how to put it - but you ended up coming out at a time when life - when people are typically less sexually active because of how the body ages. Did you feel bad that it was at that stage in life - it was only at that stage in life that you were able to to be open?

GREY: No. Ultimately, I was enjoying my life so much, and I was doing some of the best work I'd ever done. And I just thought that that was something that was not possible for me because of all the early stuff. And I came to grips with that and was happy for everybody else and happy for me in my life with my children and my friends and my career.

GROSS: Can I ask if you have a partner?

GREY: I do not.

GROSS: Would you like to?

GREY: (Laughter) I don't know why - I have great, great friends, very intimate relationships, but I've found a peace living, making photographs, acting in great shows like "Chicago" and "Wicked" and "Anything Goes" and loving my cohorts in those shows. It seems my life is pretty full.

GROSS: So just one other "Cabaret" question - you've been so identified with the role and were so extraordinary in the role of the emcee. When Alan Cumming started doing the role in revivals, did you go see him and...

GREY: I did.

GROSS: What was it like for you to watch somebody, you know, like reinterpret the role, build on what you'd done but do things that you couldn't have done onstage in the 1960s that he did in the revivals in the - was it 2000s?

GREY: I wish you had seen the original production. It was shocking to people.

GROSS: (Unintelligible). I never saw the show. I've only seen the movie. I was too young, I think, to see the show.

GREY: It was really, really - they'd never seen anything like it, and the girls were very scantily dressed for 1966 - 50 years in November (laughter). And I was disgusting and outrageous.

GROSS: (Laughter).

GREY: And it became a great piece of theater. And when Alan and Rob and Sam reimagined it, it was very, very - it was like a whole other show - excellent, but not really. It was still about anti-Semitism and Berlin in the '30s, but from another viewpoint - and so many wonderful actors have been in it since that - it's a classic role.

GROSS: Well, Joel Grey, it's just been great to talk with you again. Thank you.

GREY: Delighted.

DAVIES: Terry Gross speaking with Joel Grey in February. Last week, he received the Oscar Hammerstein Award for lifetime achievement in musical theater. Grey's memoir is called "Master Of Ceremonies." This is FRESH AIR.
DAVE DAVIES, HOST:

This is FRESH AIR. Every year sees the release of Christmas albums and singles by pop music artists. The tradition goes back decades, sometimes yielding big hits, including Bing Crosby's "White Christmas," Elvis Presley's "Blue Christmas" and Alvin and the Chipmunks "Christmas Don't Be Late." Country Artist Kacey Musgraves has released a collection titled "A Very Kacey Christmas." Rock critic Ken Tucker has a review.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "HAVE YOURSELF A VERY LITTLE CHRISTMAS")

KACEY MUSGRAVES: (Singing) Have yourself a very little Christmas. Let your heart be light. From now on, our troubles will be out of sight. Have yourself...

KEN TUCKER, BYLINE: Kacey Musgraves leads off her "Very Kacey Christmas" album with that imaginative interpretation of "Have Yourself A Merry Little Christmas." It's keening pedal steel guitar complementing Musgrave's fulsome crooning. Musgraves has made her reputation as a singer and writer of tart working-class country songs ever since her first album, 2013's "Same Trailer, Different Park."

On this album, she digs into Elvis Presley "Blue Christmas" territory with such melancholy songs as this original composition, "Christmas Makes Me Cry."

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "CHRISTMAS MAKES ME CRY")

MUSGRAVES: (Singing) It's all red and gold and Nat King Cole and tinsel on the tree. It's all twinkle and snowy nights and the kids still believe. And I know that they say, have a happy holiday. And every year, I sincerely try. Oh, but Christmas, it always makes me cry.

TUCKER: A Christmas album would be too glum if it didn't include a few novelty songs, and "A Very Kacey Christmas" is fully stocked with those. But Musgraves had a very bright idea in doing a version of "Christmas Don't Be Late," better known to baby boomers as "The Chipmunk Song" released in the late 1950s by the high-pitched voices of Alvin and the Chipmunks, created by songwriter Ross Bagdasarian. Musgraves takes this chirpy little tune, which was conceived to get laughs by being irritating, and sings it straight, turning it into a pretty waltz.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "CHRISTMAS DONT BE LATE")

MUSGRAVES: (Singing) Christmas, Christmastime is near. Time for tears and time for cheer. I've been good but I can't last. Hurry Christmas, hurry fast. Want a plane that loops the loop and I want a hula hoop. I can hardly stand the wait. Please Christmas, don't be late.

TUCKER: Musgraves is not resistant to devising her own novelty material. You get the feeling that once she came up with the phrase a willie nice Christmas, it was only a matter of time before she put in a call to Willie Nelson to get his blessing and a backup vocal to put the finishing touches on this woozy tune about, quote, "staying higher than the angel on the top of the tree."

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "A WILLIE NICE CHRISTMAS")

MUSGRAVES: (Singing) I'm going to wrap my presents up in red bandanas and leave some special cookies out for Santa. Throw my troubles to the wind till we're back on the road again. Here's to finding your own little peace on earth. And I hope you have a really, a really, really, Willie nice Christmas if you're in Luckenbach or Waikiki. I hope you have a really, a really, really Willie nice Christmas.

KACEY MUSGRAVES AND WILLIE NELSON: (Singing) And may we all stay higher than the angel on the top of the tree.

WILLIE NELSON: (Singing) Don't get caught up...

TUCKER: The high point of this collection is another new original song, "Ribbons And Bows." Arranged to sound like a 1960s girl group song, it finds Musgraves singing through handclaps and a saxophone riff to achieve a harder edge than most nostalgia-tinged holiday songs.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "RIBBONS AND BOWS")

MUSGRAVES: (Singing) I don't need ribbons and bows to cure my woes. No, I just need your love. Expensive rings or diamond things, no, I just need your love. Don't get me wrong, shiny new Mercedes would look nice in my driveway. Or a roundtrip ticket for a long vacation on a big fancy jet plane. There's only one thing that I want, baby, it's hard to find and it's already mine. I don't need ribbons and bows...

TUCKER: There's real artistic development in evidence on "A Very Kacey Christmas." Musgrave's vocals on her earlier albums can sometimes sound thin or a bit strained. She was inventive in using her limitations to dramatize emotional stress. On this album, however, Musgraves has become a much more confident vocalist. Listen to the way she takes command of Frank Loesser's 1947 song "What Are You Doing New Year's Eve?"

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "WHAT ARE YOU DOING NEW YEAR'S EVE?")

MUSGRAVES: (Singing) When the bells are ringing and the horns all blow and the couples that we know are finally kissing, will I be with you or will I be among the missing? Maybe it's much too early in the game, oh, but I thought I'd ask you just the same, what are you doing New Year's, New Year's Eve? Wonder whose arms...

TUCKER: Most Christmas albums are throwaway work, executed quickly for some holiday cash as background music as you trim the tree and swill eggnog. With A Very Kasey Christmas, however, Kacey Musgraves has made the rare Christmas album that can be listened to closely from start to finish with both pleasure and admiration.

DAVIES: Ken Tucker is critic-at-large at yahoo.com. He reviewed Kacey Musgraves' new album "A Very Kacey Christmas." On tomorrow's show, fake news in the presidential election. We'll speak with BuzzFeed media editor Craig Silverman, who spent years writing about accuracy in media. He'll tell us why teenagers in a small town in Macedonia run websites spinning tall tales about American politics and why so many of us are willing to believe stories that aren't true. Hope you can join us.

FRESH AIR's executive producer is Danny Miller. Our senior producer is Roberta Shorrock. Our interviews and reviews are produced and edited by Amy Salit, Phyllis Myers, Ann Marie Baldonado, Sam Briger, Lauren Krenzel, John Sheehan, Heidi Saman, Therese Madden and Mooj Zadie. For Terry Gross, I'm Dave Davies.

(SOUNDBITE OF SONG, "I'VE GOT MY LOVE TO KEEP ME WARM")

BILLIE HOLIDAY: (Singing) The snow is snowing, wind is blowing, but I can weather the storm. What do I care how much it may storm? I've got my love to keep me warm. I can't remember a worse December, watch those icicles fall. What do I care if icicles fall? I've got my love to keep me warm. Off with my overcoat, off with my glove. I need no overcoat, I'm burning with love. My heart's on fire. The flame grows higher. So I will weather the storm. What do I care how much it may storm?

Transcripts are created on a rush deadline, and accuracy and availability may vary. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. Please be aware that the authoritative record of Fresh Air interviews and reviews are the audio recordings of each segment.